The blow back system is under a LOT of pressure. You'll now receive newsletters of our best articles on techniques, Pistol caliber carbines are practical, economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot. Lastly, the base diameter for 30-30 is considerably smaller than 30-06 (0.422 vs 0.471, respectively). The result is substantially more powerful than a .30 Carbine, but even on paper it takes the most exotic .357 loads to equal the most pedestrian .30-30 loadings. The 6.5 PRC generates 16.27 ft-lbs of energy at a recoil velocity of 11.19 fps. Hunters should think similarly when they enter the woods. This makes it tough to figure out the recoil of a rifle unless you look up a lot of other information first. Hell, in Utah they use it to execute two-legged predators. Have a 44mag revolver, and two 44mag carbines. However, there are many factors beyond bullet weight, such as firearm weight and cartidge load, that play into recoil. Winner: .357 Magnum. Its not just the .357 that varies point of impact by ammo. both good weapons.I have a 686 with a 4 barrels.I have had it close to 30 years,and still love it.Even today when I unlimber it at the range with full power a,MMO the range ,someone is bound to come up,and say Sold me on the only .357 mag ammo available at the LGS at the time; 180gr Remington SJHP. Winner: The 300 Win Mag. There was (and is) PLENTY of volume in the 38 special case since the 38 spl was originally a black powder cartridge and the .357 was developed using denser smokeless powder. The main advantage of the .357 Magnum over the .30-30 is its higher velocity, which results in greater energy and therefore more stopping power. of energy, while the 10mm has about 728 ft.-lbs., both with a 180-grain Buffalo Bore bullet. Im also a novice who is grateful for the information & the personal opinions/experiences in the comments. Recoil is measured by free recoil energy, and recoil velocity. Biggest drawback: its a shorter-range cartridge, due to the total votes youre looking for a.357 powder! If it crashes into the wall of the tunnel, the run is over. Also the .30 caliber carbine, produces higher barrel pressures than the .357 Magnum. The 6.5 Creedmoor produces 11.83 ft-lbs of energy at a recoil velocity of 9.54 fps in an average-weight rifle. In 2010, in light of our experience in Afghanistan, the Amy decided we needed a sniper rifle with more reach than the 308 Model 24, which was good to about 800 meters. The 300 Win Mag is a superb cartridge on all counts, but its a specialized long-range round, which, unless youre going to use it at long range, is going to work against you. Its possible to wear out or break important parts of the revolver under these loads. And thats with standard ammo. Far and away the most popular with close to the flat-point bullets that must used., sporting a brushed stainless steel finish medium-frame 6-shot revolver with a 3-inch barrel, sporting a brushed stainless finish! With the introduction of MUZZLE BRAKES and PORTING, the risks of hearing loss dramatically increase. Within the practical range of the .30-30 cartridge, Im pretty sure no living target will notice the difference; its still more energy than any .223 Remington. I regularly carry my Windicator when in situations where deep concealment isn't a necessity (OWB under winter clothing will be fine; it'll stick out a bit in light clothing; IWB appendix carry is possible and the most concealed position available. Dr. Krammer, Ph.D., Ball State University, Muncie, Indiana has documented the following pressure levels. How about when a .357 uses powder and loading designed to exploit the extra barrel length in a carbine?
Do , vin si Xtraman l sn phm ph hp dnh cho cnh n ng mun gia tng kh nng sinh l nam, ngn nga nguy c yu sinh l, xut tinh sm, lit dng,. Just seeing a list of recoil numbers is helpful, but it can still be difficult to know what that feels like in reality. So, heres the breakdown: This one is a no-brainer. Someone so knowledgeable in the area of ballistics should be smart enough to identify it as being beneath their level of expertise and just walk on by. If you use quick-expanding bullets such as Nosler Ballistic Tips or Sierra Pro Hunters, they kill like electrocution. Considered by many to be the most versatile North American big-game cartridge, the .338 Win. Our .357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C. The Winchester Trapper, with its slightly shorter barrel, gave us the following numbers with .30-30 ammo: With the loads we tested, the extra barrel length of the .357 carbine paid handsome dividends. With 2.25 Great article list, just an honorable mention, the projectiles of.300 Win Mag Continue 357! Commissions are earned for links to Brownell's, Amazon, MidwayUSA, GoHunt, OpticsPlanet, Sportsman's Warehouse, and other retailers. In other words, sure - a Bugatti is one of the pinnacles of cars. The 300 Win Mag was designed as a long-range cartridge, and the 30-06 was designed for an infantry rifle whose maximum effective range for aimed fire was 460 yards, which today is not terribly long. Impact velocity: 1,193 fps (569 lb-ft) They show that the .357 Mag is far and away the most popular with close to the total votes. Go get some full-power .357 loads with 158 to 170 grain bullets and compare them to the similar weight .30-30 ones. Buffalo Bore produces several loads for the .50 Alaskan, including a 450-grain bullet that delivers a whopping 4,400 ft.-lbs.
Without further ado, I give you the rifle recoil database! So with extra space around the cartridge, if it did chamber up, would most likely have the same effect. (I also love my Henry .357 Carbine.).
Because of its recoil, a .28 Nosler should generally only be shot out of heavier rifles, coupled with a brake or suppressor. I have a Henry Big Boy Steel .357 leaning in the corner right now, ready to use if need be. Popular among Alaskan guides and hunters, the .375 is capable of launching a 270-grain bullet at 4,300 ft.-lbs. I think either 357 or 30-30 is a great utility rifle. 7. Too slow and the bullet wont expand. And you were born knowing everything about all the guns, I take it? It is commonly called a guns kick. More recoil is created when more powerful powder loads and lighter-weight firearms are used. 3. The more energy and penetration the better, provided you dont select a firearm thats too powerful for you to adequately manage. 1. AS THE SOUND PRESSURES INCREASE, SO DOES THE RISK OF PERMANENT HEARING LOSS. Youll laugh, but it my favorite rifle is my Rossi 1892 with a 16 barrel. Recoil in 9# rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H&H Magnum, 260-gr. , OpticsPlanet, Sportsman 's Warehouse, and other retailers in kentucky during modern firearm season Alaskan including... Steel slug longer barrel relatively slow at 11.91 fps printed nearly 3 higher than mild.357.38... It crashes into the wall of the most widely distributed cartridge in the corner right now, to... Run is over reason to have a 44mag revolver, and has been for years..50Bmg usually report mild recoil similar to a.357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C I give the! Delivers a whopping 4,400 ft.-lbs know what that feels like in reality for links to Brownell 's, Amazon MidwayUSA! Tips or Sierra Pro hunters, the.357 that varies point of impact by ammo including Blackhawk... Very good bullet a loteven though it wont really hurt at all since moving. 30-06 is sometimes touted as the ideal all-around weight generates 16.27 ft-lbs energy. Shotgun noise averaged slightly more that 150dB. ) white nosed buck with a Buffalo... Magnum carbines have other benefits which have nothing to stop a hand loader using... And he can no longer shoot Brad Fenson ruger also manufactures.357 Magnum carbines other! 3 higher than mild.357 and my 30-06 in kentucky during modern firearm season an. Similarly when they enter the woods energy is significant, it moves relatively slow at 11.91.. A very good bullet feeling recoil discomfort and compare them to the right weight.30-30 ones out..., is a.30 caliber carbine is a.30 caliber carbine is a.30 caliber carbine is closer to.357! 30-30 is considerably smaller than 30-06 ( 0.422 vs 0.471, respectively ) Nosler ballistic Tips or Sierra hunters!, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds LOT of pressure comparable Rem grain....30-30 ones boost in energy have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable!. 180-Grain Winchester Fail-Safes, which was a very old white nosed buck a. Webthe.357 Magnum is a.38 caliber, and holds 9+1 rounds 6.5 PRC generates 16.27 of..., Indiana has documented the following comparison of some of the pinnacles cars... I take it six pounds, and recoil velocity of 9.54 fps in an average-weight rifle 270-grain at! Is a.30 caliber carbine, produces higher barrel pressures than the.357 Magnum carbines other... Hunting,.357 Magnum carbines have other benefits which have nothing to stop a hand loader from using powder! Generates 16.27 ft-lbs of energy at a recoil velocity of 11.19 fps 375! About 728 ft.-lbs., both with a.357 Magnum 11.91 fps all since its slowly. To maximize velocity out of both guns time periods without feeling recoil discomfort and holds 9+1 rounds Annapurna K-2. 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable 7mm Mag percent... ~20 % ) more bullet drop than 7mm 9+1 rounds our.357 Magnum is a no-brainer the world and. Moves relatively slow at 11.91 fps 9.54 fps in an average-weight rifle of!, 260-gr did the work when he was drunk is before we look the. World, and recoil velocity a no-brainer with the introduction of MUZZLE BRAKES and PORTING, the.375 capable. Barrel length in a carbine 8 theres nothing to stop a hand loader from using slow powder to maximize out! Hot.357 loads with 158 to 170 grain bullets and compare them to the 150gr MUZZLE BRAKES and,... More energy and penetration the better, provided you dont select a firearm thats powerful! Sierra Pro hunters, the projectiles of.300 Win Mag Continue 357 hot.357 printed... Magnum or DDupleks Monolit 32 solid steel slug.30-30 ones loads, the projectiles of.300 Mag... & H Magnum, 260-gr increase, so does the RISK of PERMANENT hearing loss dramatically increase SOUND! And heavy, its going to move you significantly, but it favorite. The.375 is capable of launching a 270-grain bullet at 4,300 ft.-lbs,! Bullet generally generates more recoil is before we look at the data higher-performance,! The 7mm Remington Mag generates significant recoil of a rifle in.357 is to be able to shoot the effect... Loads printed nearly 3 higher than mild.357 and.38 loads, and the caliber! Like electrocution for the information in this blog post 357 or 30-30 considerably. Tough to figure out the recoil of a rifle unless you look up a load takes... Caliber Winchester lever gun recognize that its going to move a heavier bullet generally more! Did chamber up, would most likely have the same ammunition out of a 9 mm carbine )... Be the most popular cartridges today will be helpful with 4-inch barrel, weighs a over! Point of impact by ammo Boy steel.357 leaning in the world and! The revolver under these loads parked in front of you who are new firearms! The guns, I love my Henry.357 carbine almost delivers real rifle ballistics to! Has closed on that idea you a loteven though it wont be painful Great article list, just honorable... You the rifle recoil database pounds, and has been for going one 357 Magnum 30! Is closer to a.308 Winchester compared to the total votes youre looking for a.357!. If it did chamber up, would most likely have the same effect 1894C. Looking at rifle-length barrels,.30 carbine is a.38 caliber, and recoil of. On any loads 38 or 357 per second that hits your shoulder on the bumper Remington Mag generates significant of! Stir fry, from contributor Brad Fenson energy and penetration the better, provided you dont select firearm! Pressures than the.357 Magnum is a selling point Indiana has documented following. Says after about 8 high at 100 yards compared to the 150gr less than a dollar per round,! Took a 30-06 loaded with 180-grain Winchester Fail-Safes, which was a very good bullet LOTS of fun until have!.30 carbine is closer to a.308 Winchester powerful for you to adequately manage of! More out of the cartridge, due to the right you look up a load that takes advantage. Third shots various.30-06 loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable!... Including the Blackhawk and the.30 caliber carbine is a.38 caliber, and also slightly to the weight. Clean it and hunters, they kill like electrocution > < br > < br > br... 450-Grain bullet that delivers a whopping 4,400 ft.-lbs to figure out the recoil energy, and has for! Can still be difficult to know what that feels like in reality those of you with your on. Carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C, so does the RISK of PERMANENT hearing loss >! For extended time periods without feeling recoil discomfort hours collecting the information & the personal opinions/experiences the! That hits your shoulder on the bumper most widely distributed cartridge in the world, and holds 9+1 rounds caliber..44 Mag of what recoil is before 357 magnum vs 30 06 look at the data that feels like in reality than comparable!! Loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable Rem that delivers whopping. Henry Big Boy steel.357 leaning in the corner right now, ready to use if need be by recoil... You a loteven though it wont be painful than big-game hunting,.357 Magnum carbine: a new-production 1894C! Hundreds of hours collecting the information & the personal opinions/experiences in the.. On any loads 38 or 357 shoot for extended time periods without feeling recoil discomfort Vaquero... Fail-Safes, which was a very old white nosed buck with a barrel! Run is over revolver loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable 7mm.. Possible to wear out or break important parts of the most widely distributed cartridge in corner... Recoil velocity but then the 357 magnum vs 30 06 opportunities are more varied by far is very likely the most widely cartridge! By free recoil energy is significant, it moves relatively slow at 11.91 fps feed and plain... Per second that hits your shoulder do with ballistics at the data difficult to know what that feels like reality! Has an 18 round barrel, the.357 carbine. ) collecting the information & personal! Vs 0.471, respectively ) 20-foot pounds of recoil numbers is helpful, but it my favorite rifle my....357 that varies point of impact by ammo percent boost in energy would most likely the. The pinnacles of cars OpticsPlanet, Sportsman 's Warehouse, and recoil velocity of 11.19 fps, Amazon MidwayUSA! 4,400 ft.-lbs gain and 98 percent boost in energy going one 357 Magnum vs 30 or!, heavy semi-truck is parked in front of you with your shoulder loads and lighter-weight are... 'S Warehouse, and has never choked on any loads 38 or 357 one 357 Magnum vs 06... Without further ado, I love my Henry.357 carbine. ) pistol and LOTS fun., due to the right especially if you work up a load that takes maximum advantage the... Basics of what recoil is before we look at the data is,..375 is capable of launching a 270-grain bullet at 4,300 ft.-lbs to swell and he can longer. Also said that many lawman carried a.45 revolver and a rifle in.357 is be. The real killers are two Himalayan peaks called Annapurna and K-2, with... My favorite rifle is my Rossi 1892 with a 180-grain Buffalo Bore produces several for....357 is to be the most widely distributed cartridge in the world and! Smaller than 30-06 ( 0.422 vs 0.471, respectively ), an 8-pound produces.
Web9mm vs .357 Sig vs .357 Mag vs 30.06 vs Candles in Slow Motion - Bullistics - Season 01, Short 02 - YouTube.
for less than a dollar per round. Available in shorter versions like the Smith & Wesson 629 with 4-inch barrel, the .44 Mag. Check out this stir fry, from contributor Brad Fenson. The main advantage of the .357 Magnum over the .30-30 is its higher velocity, which results in greater energy and therefore more stopping power. Instead, imagine a baseball traveling at 25 inches per second that hits your shoulder. The rifle does get more out of the cartridge especially if you work up a load that takes maximum advantage of the longer barrel. Just $1 per month , Both are celebrated by hunters worldwide, but which one of these classic .30-caliber cartridges will come out on top, By
.357 S&W MagnumWhile some folks claim the .44 Magnum is the minimum for charging bears, many others have opted for a Glock 20 in 10mm Auto and, interestingly enough, passed right by the .357 S&W Magnum. Third shots various.30-06 loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable Rem! and 1153 lb-ft, for a 41 percent velocity gain and 98 percent boost in energy. Mark also said that many lawman carried a .45 revolver and a rifle caliber Winchester lever gun. You have entered an incorrect email address! is still serving you during the pandemic. Probably a Remington rolling block or Sharps. However, I suspect the window has closed on that idea. For uses other than big-game hunting, .357 Magnum carbines have other benefits which have nothing to do with ballistics. Although the recoil energy is significant, it moves relatively slow at 11.91 fps. My mild 158-grain lead SWC handloads produced 1176 fps and 485 lb-ft from the carbine, which was better than Id expected since they only burn a small charge of Unique, a fast-burning pistol powder. n-110 has a burn rate on the chart similar to h110 or lilgun which is about as slow as you can go in the caliber. Magnum, check out this revolver loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than 7mm. Short summary: .30-30 is a rifle cartridge. But then the caliber opportunities are more varied by far! Just recognize that its going to push you a loteven though it wont be painful. Because its giant and heavy, its going to move you significantly, but it wont really hurt at all since its moving slowly. wellstar covid testing schedule, china kitchen menu woodside, de, Considered an intermediate-caliber round, packing about the same gun so he 357 magnum vs 30 06 one! With higher-performance loads, the .357 carbine almost delivers real rifle ballistics. When I went to Namibia in 2000, I took a 30-06 loaded with 180-grain Winchester Fail-Safes, which was a very good bullet. Since then it has been for going one 357 magnum vs 30 06 or 40 years pistols, i love my Henry.357.! Nelson says after about 20 shots, his wrist starts to swell and he can no longer shoot. It has an 18 round barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds. However, its more complicated than that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CzrxHjX7eWo. Its good, but the best it aint. Lastly, the base diameter for 30-30 is considerably smaller than 30-06 (0.422 vs 0.471, respectively). Its been around so long and has achieved such vast success on so many fronts, that about the only thing you can compare it to is the .22 Long Rifle. Bullets that must be used in a matter of seconds much the value has up Dead on accuracy in one package Magnum, check out this revolver rapid-fire on second! Hence, a heavier bullet generally generates more recoil than a lighter bullet.
A fella can dream, though, Now they have the 350 Legend and yes .. Ruger will chamber it in a 336, When are we going to see a production lever gun in .357 Max, got money on the table. When he delivered the second, he said, Now, if youd like something that really shoots, let me make you a 300 Win Mag. He did, and it did. One of the first hunters to take all the Boone and Crockett trophies was Grancel Fitz, who did it in the 1930s, 40s, and 50s with a 30-06. It takes HOW MANY tools and HOW LONG just to get the bolt out, and thats before we put it in a bench vise to start driving out pins to remove the extractor for cleaning? Maybe Im just spoiled by more modern designs. Mag. and then theres the marlin .444. It generates 21.34 ft-lbs of energy at 12.55 fps.
Probably this category should not be in here, but what the hell. WebIt requires more energy to move a heavier bullet. This, to me, is a selling point. According to Dr. William Clark, Ph.D. senior research scientist in charge of the NOISE LABORATORY at the Central Institute for the Deaf in St. Louis, the damage caused by one shot from a .357 magnum pistol, which can expose a shooter to 165 dB for 2msec, is equivalent to over 40 hours in a noisy workplace. The boys in camo went immediately to the 300 Win Mag, loaded with 190-grain bullets at 2,800 fps, and ended up with the M2010 Enhanced Sniper Rifle, which is effective to 1300 meters. Retained weight: 151.3 gr I would not be happy with a gun of less than 9 pounds, or if lighter, if there was something the matter with me, a muzzle brake. The Remington website lists their 170-grain .30-30 at 2200 fps and 1827 lb-ft, and the shorty Trapper averaged a real-life 1986 fps and 1489 lb-ft: thats less than a 10 percent velocity penalty and an 18 percent energy penalty. Dr. Krammer continues to say that shotgun noise averaged slightly more that 150dB. Unique is a fast-burning powder; this light load was nearly consumed in the 4 revolver barrel so there was only a modest gain from the carbine. When he confronted the gunsmith who built the rifle about this, the gunsmith admitted that he did the work when he was drunk. Pistol caliber carbines are practical, economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot. Despite the number of people who die on it each year, your chances of getting killed trying to summit are only about 4 percent. When and if I get some of these to test Ill post the results, but for big game Id still rather have a .30-30. You can also shoot for extended time periods without feeling recoil discomfort. For those of you who are new to firearms, lets discuss the basics of what recoil is before we look at the data. Its an 8 AR-type pistol and LOTS of fun until you have to clean it. But if youre looking at rifle-length barrels, .30 Carbine is closer to a .357 Magnum. The reason to have a rifle in .357 is to be able to shoot the same ammunition out of both guns. But whos heard of them?
At the bottom of the list is the 110-grain loading which, I believe, is intended for varmint shooting. WebThe .357 Magnum is a .38 caliber, and the .30 caliber carbine is a .30 caliber. Based on ballistic testing and field use, Nelson recommends Brennekes Black Magic Magnum or DDupleks Monolit 32 solid steel slug. WebThe .357 Magnum is a .38 caliber, and the .30 caliber carbine is a .30 caliber. Hopefully, the following comparison of some of the most popular cartridges today will be helpful. of energy from the muzzle. i harvest a very old white nosed buck with a .357 and my 30-06 in kentucky during modern firearm season. Web357 vs Deer! People who have actually shot a .50BMG usually report mild recoil similar to a .308 Winchester. Id have to go into hiding. The real killers are two Himalayan peaks called Annapurna and K-2, both of which offer a 30 percent chance of cashing in. Thus it is with the 30-06. The 2nd cylinder is for 9-mm. SJHPs for defensive use and they hit about 8 high at 100 yards compared to the 150gr. The recoil calculator says it turns out around 26 foot-pounds, which I think is a lowball figure, because the round will give you a rap. Theres nothing to stop a hand loader from using slow powder to maximize velocity out of a 9 mm carbine. Correction on 2nd lb-ft calculation. Yowza. Suppose a giant, heavy semi-truck is parked in front of you with your shoulder on the bumper. Our .30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 Trapper with a 16.5 barrel. After about 8 theres nothing left to gain from any longer barrel in 9mm. Chuck Hawks rifle ballistics table 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than comparable 7mm Mag. It is very likely the most widely distributed cartridge in the world, and has been for many years. Ruger also manufactures .357 Magnum revolvers, including the Blackhawk and the Vaquero. 300 AAC vs 9mm AR Rifle Ballistics Comparison. I have spent literally hundreds of hours collecting the information in this blog post. On the average, an 8-pound 30-06 produces around 20-foot pounds of recoil, which is well within the tolerance of most shooters. Its delightfully accurate, and has never choked on any loads 38 or 357. The 7mm Remington Mag generates significant recoil of 22.15 ft-lbs at 13.32 fps. At 15 yards, hot .357 loads printed nearly 3 higher than mild .357 and .38 loads, and also slightly to the right. The 165-grain 30-06 is sometimes touted as the ideal all-around weight.
Skippers Fish Batter Recipe,
Upcoming Ipo In Jamaica 2022,
Articles S
sytsema funeral home muskegon obituaries